Color Comparison- True metallic metal

Introduction:

With the upcoming Hexfire release i decided to paint some Grey Knights. I also thought this is maybe a good time to figure out some prejudice with metallic colors the community has in mind.

Most miniature painters say that GW metallic colors are bad for painting becuase of there small proportion to metallic pigments and the thickness.

With my ongoing research to what colors i will bench against each other i also find out that there are diffrent primers that will have impact on the result of painting metallic metal. So i decided also to bench the results of a regular primer and a metallic primer. The research also showed up that most of the pro painters that using true metallic metal colors using vallejo or GW colors to paint there models.

This is why i came up to paint 4 models at the end of the day. I needed to paint 2 diffrent color types with 2 diffrent primers.

I marked all the modells at the bottom with a series of letters to define how they will get painted.

Definition of marks

  • VM GW – vallejo matt primer, Games Workshop colors
  • VG GW – vallejo gloss primer, Games Workshop colors
  • VM V – vallejo matt primer, vallejo colors
  • VG V – vallejo gloss primer, vallejo colors

But before we start to paint lets take a lookon all the colors i used for the comparsion.

Primers

  • vallejo – Black surface primer (74.602) – matt
  • vallejo – Black surface primer (77.660) – gloss

Games Workshop metallics

  • Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
  • Citadel (Layer) – Runefang Steel
  • Citadel (Layer) – Stormhost Silver

vallejo metallics

  • vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
  • vallejo – Silver (77.724)
  • vallejo – Aluminium (77.701)

General colors – All models

  • vallejo – Black (70.950)
  • vallejo – White (70.951)
  • vallejo – Royal Blue (70.809)
  • vallejo – Deep Sky Blue (70.844)
  • Citadel (Base) – Celestra Grey
  • Citadel (Layer) – Dark Reaper
  • Citadel (Layer) – Ulthuan Grey
  • Citadel (Base) – Mephiston Red
  • Citadel (Layer) – Evil Sunz Scarlet
  • Citadel (Layer) – Wild Rider Red
  • Citadel (Base) – Zandri Dust
  • Citadel (Layer) – Ushabti Bone
  • Citadel (Layer) – Screaming Skull
  • Citadel (Shade) – Darkenhof Nightshade
  • Citadel (Shade) – Nuln oil
  • Citadel (Shade) – Agrax Earthshade
  • Citadel (Shade) – Carroburg Crimson

Varnish

  • vallejo – Metal varnish (77.657)

The Basecoating Process

vallejo – Black surface primer (74.602) – matt
vallejo – Black surface primer (77.660) – gloss
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)

Shading

matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)

Edge Highlighting

matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)

Painted details

matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)

Varnish

matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
matt primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
matt primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)
gloss primer / Citadel (Base) – Leadbelcher
gloss primer / vallejo – Dark Aluminium (77.703)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Consent Management Platform by Real Cookie Banner